Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

58 Methodist Island
Port McNicoll Tay L0K 1R0

$899,900
Residential Freehold beds: 3 baths: 2.0

Main Photo: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 1: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 2: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 3: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 4: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 5: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 6: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 7: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 8: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 9: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 10: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 11: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 12: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 13: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 14: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 15: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 16: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 17: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 18: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 19: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 20: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 21: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 22: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 23: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 24: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Photo 25: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
S13227130
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
2
A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
Bungalow
Total Approx Floor Area:
1100-1500
Lot Depth:
220'
Lot Frontage:
77'1"
Direction Faces:
East
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
2.0
Water supply:
Other
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
8
Heating type:
Baseboard
Heating Fuel:
Electric
Foundation:
Piers
Roof:
Metal
Basement:
None
Fireplace/Stove:
No
Alternative Power:
None
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
0.0
Family Room:
Yes
Possession Details:
TBD
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Taxes:
$3,669.47 / 2025
Assessment:
$- / -
Simcoe
Tay
Port McNicoll
Carpet Free, Water Heater Owned
Unknown
Fridge, cooktop, wall oven, washer, dryer, hot tub, dock, freezer, furniture, BBQ
None
Board & Batten
253'
Dock
Direct
Sandy
None
Direct
Water Only
Georgian Bay
Bay
Not Applicable
Marina
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Kitchen
30'8" × 17'1"
Main
Living Room
17'1" × 16'6"
Main
Bedroom
14'8" × 13'4"
Main
Bedroom 2
10'4" × 9'7¾"
Main
Bedroom 3
14'2" × 10'4"
Main
Sunroom
10'11" × 9'1"
Floor
Ensuite
Pieces
Other
Main
No
4
10'4" x 4'1" 4 Pc Bath
Main
Yes
3
6'11" x 3'8⅞" 3 Pc Ensuite
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Septic
Air Conditioning:
None
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Date Listed:
Jun 02, 2026
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 1 of 25
  • Photo 2: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 2 of 25
  • Photo 3: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 3 of 25
  • Photo 4: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 4 of 25
  • Photo 5: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 5 of 25
  • Photo 6: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 6 of 25
  • Photo 7: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 7 of 25
  • Photo 8: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 8 of 25
  • Photo 9: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 9 of 25
  • Photo 10: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 10 of 25
  • Photo 11: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 11 of 25
  • Photo 12: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 12 of 25
  • Photo 13: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 13 of 25
  • Photo 14: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 14 of 25
  • Photo 15: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 15 of 25
  • Photo 16: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 16 of 25
  • Photo 17: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 17 of 25
  • Photo 18: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 18 of 25
  • Photo 19: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 19 of 25
  • Photo 20: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 20 of 25
  • Photo 21: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 21 of 25
  • Photo 22: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 22 of 25
  • Photo 23: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 23 of 25
  • Photo 24: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 24 of 25
  • Photo 25: 58 Methodist Island in Tay: Port McNicoll House for sale : MLS®# S13227130
    Photo 25 of 25
Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
Data was last updated June 24, 2026 at 02:15 AM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
35
Avg list price:
$629,900
Min list price:
$299,900
Max list price:
$2,199,900
Avg days on market:
56
Min days on market:
4
Max days on market:
708
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Port McNicoll. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.